Judge Justice Chamberlain ruled that McCormack caused severe harm to Wright’s reputation. But because Wright had falsified evidence in the trial, the judge opted to award the Claimant nominal damages of just £1.
“However, because he advanced a deliberately false case and put forward deliberately false evidence until days before trial, he will recover only nominal damages.”
Wright’s legal team claimed victory
Between March and October 2019, McCormack posted several tweets, and a statement during a YouTube discussion, to the effect that Wright is not Satoshi Nakamoto.
In response, Wright filed a legal claim in April 2019 on the grounds that McCormack’s actions had damaged his reputation on 16 counts.
The trial was heard between May 23 and 25, in which evidence was presented of McCormack asserting that the Claimant is not Bitcoin creator Satoshi Nakamoto. This included tweets that read:
“Craig Wright is a fraud, bring it or go jogging.”
“I confirm receipt of your letter regarding Craig Wright, who in my professional opinion is definitely not the person behind the pseudonym Satoshi Nakamoto”
Judge Chamberlain concluded that “it would not be a proportionate use of judicial resources” to “resolve the differences between the parties,” i.e., no ruling was made on Wright being Satoshi Nakamoto.
By email, Simon Cohen of the law firm ONTIER LLP, representing Wright, said the ruling had successfully exposed McCormack’s “deliberate campaign” to defame the Claimant. Commenting on the falsification of evidence, Cohen said the legal team is reviewing the judgment “with a view to appealing the interpretation of Dr. Wright’s evidence.”
McCormack is pleased with the ruling
In response to the publication of the case findings, McCormack thanked his legal team and Judge Chamberlain for the outcome. However, he also mentioned that “the process is not complete,” and will refrain from passing further comments in the meantime.
As some of you will now have seen, the judgement in my trial v Dr. Craig Wright has now been handed down.
I want to thank my lawyers for their diligent work on the case.
I also want to thank Mr Justice Chamberlain for this result. We are very pleased with his findings.
— Pedro ☠️ (@PeterMcCormack) August 1, 2022
The comments to McCormack’s tweet contained multiple messages of congratulations and offers to cover the damages.